So if the line from Chicago to Madison is built, what train sets will be used? Will it be a continuation of what Amtrak runs on the Hiawatha line? Or is this a time to introduce a new, more attractive, rail car to the line?
First up, what is used by Amtrak right now:
The locomotive is a GE Genesis which pulls a hand full of comet rail cars.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgZLpmG7SvYgo2IV2p1H52jK4LWZb6d-6eqb9jXelskuMK_eXcjjUAoJoIv2P6R5f6KVX5VfcyymT759kACpaWySclnrbQwkGQSJzZADfCb0xRA9cwOJNeq1hU6dwToeVf53QB1IFEjcDtl/s400/TrainDepartingSturtevant.jpg)
*Note that the locomotive is an older version of the current one used. Also, this photo was taken from
here.
Now, I know this is standard Amtrak, but who says that this new rail service will be under Amtrak or needs to use the same rail stock?
So, I have compiled a list of different diesel trains that might contend for this route:
My first choice should not come as a surprise to those who know me. If I had my way, the train arriving in Madison would be an ICE-TD, made by Bombardier. This train currently runs to Berlin-Copenhagen route (the one with the boat ferry pictured below). This train is able to run up to speeds of 200 kph or 125 mph. This means that train is fast enough to meet the 110 mph goal. Also, having ridden in this train I can speak to how comfortable this train is. On the downside, it's service history is not the best.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhJFjeaPIyfN2hggAXLmf1JjbmB0qJhkV0Ctm2T2ppPJ1SOjCXjxjAawhia0KtRIRznxXj_b1X03n0dHP8lllMasYun5DKRYX2OheR-VPv9Q2INJEphWtZkCK4HG8MJJENW_C-4qhjMc4JM/s400/IMG_2898.JPG)
*This picture was taken by me when taking the train from Copenhagen to Berlin (and then transferring on to Dresden). It is in a car ferry that goes from Denmark to Germany.
Keeping on the topic of German trains, another option is the RegioSwinger. This train is like the ICE TD in that it is deisel and it tilts. However its top speed is only 160 kph or 100 mph. However, this is another train that I have taken in Germany and can vouch for it being a nice comfortable ride. I took this train from Dresden to Freiberg on the Dresden-Nürnberg line.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiAXuIaT3epJ-BuNuc4ytxx257OVGuBKVaA82YalvJLR8sUlcmYO82q2NXHGW0GNyeNKix8oZoTwJnLJKvAccDJNnrO8xM1-c9Zy1daI9U5fzah0qsRhewaCTopH7t4pk6JsTT3qaqvVUuY/s400/DBAG_Baureihe_612_Neigebetrieb_(612-009-1).jpg)
*Note that this train's destination is actually Leipzig and the photo was taken from
here.
Another one of my favorite trains is the Bombardier Talent class of trains. However, its top speed is only 140 kph or 87 mph. But just for the heck of it here is a picture of it:
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiOYC-5aIhEHHOP8HLrnJVNke4NM_uxEVyF-zkicn7Xj5KECnffIceuKL8BVQ8UHG4xZqeUkhUctvolreEjtUM9U3nYUmdqo87jj1qJeBSp1IffYq2Vq7cs6bedIcr7DUEdAELcfdKwzoGV/s400/Talent.jpg)
This train would be best served running more regional routes in Wisconsin, such as (these are just ideas) Green Bay - Wausau - Eau Claire - Minneapolis or Madison - Appleton - Green Bay or Madison -Janesville - Beloit - Rockford.
Another train that looks a lot a like the Talent is the Desiro class of trains made by Siemens. Also, they are currently in use in the US in California for the Sprinter trains. Here is a pic of the Desiro in Germany:
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj2tRjXOsNzBNYeuAhFlHxMAk0rnb28k-eGdcTfW4Cy7xwTHOqXs0MYc8lKhqA8ozQPPQw4TlD_UL0gkj0WMOO18vzQxsCv6vaWHzfCBUYVPdJBJ63JmwHtbBldytE9sqmQg1qalcWAUSwS/s400/Desiro.jpg)
There is just ONE BIG ISSUE with these trains. It is that according to FRA (Federal Railway Administration) these trains are too light to run on freight lines. That means, as the law now stands, these trains would have to run on dedicated "light" rail lines or not be allowed to operate. (Note: I'm not sure what the ICE TD is classified as)
Two trains that might be allowed are the Accela trains from the Northeast Corridor or the X2000 from Sweden.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhz3oZsNN4Z6EEffde12HR0nikWcR_7sMvKtM7_EzITHMSm8WFpUBrUuDjfl0Ums9JkMad6M8jyT5PBMbPIcBGsx9HG3ZxpOELTnt70qHb7UylIJDGrMWGI0pS9SRimEmmBrZUbkk-p40Lx/s400/Acela_overhead_view.jpg)
This a picture of the Acela Express just south of downtown Boston. The major issue with using this train is that it requires overhead electrical wires. These are more environmentally friendly than diesel power systems. Also, most other countries use the overhead wire system.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjM_lyULKwY8s-0CR3qX7aI_xZ3EmCkc3mzNuJ1jpmvYCeS9jsvY0lKVfaXIWWJGydPeKKjZAk1WS0vtxY8cxnAijodznrOTC6beCdAgaE4wC79tG_2z16oHW4PKP2p_igJQZohZC2tJtik/s400/IMG_2340.JPG)
This is a picture of me in front of a X2000 train is Sundsvall, Sweden. This train is also electrically powered. Also in the background is the train I was transferring to, a
Regina train, destination Ostersund, Sweden.
I feel that it would be beneficial to convert US rail lines to an all electrical system. But that's a topic for another time...